Skip to content
, ,

·

6 min read

One Year After the FDA Removed the Hormone Therapy Black Box Warning: What Women Should Know Now

Menopause · 6 min read

A woman walking along a coastal bluff above the ocean

For more than twenty years, many women were afraid to even ask about hormone therapy. One year ago this month, that changed. Since then, my patients have been bringing me headlines, social media posts and a lot of good questions. Here is what has actually changed, what the newest research says, and what I think every woman should know before she decides.

What changed a year ago

On November 10, 2025, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration announced that it would remove the boxed warning, often called the “black box,” from menopausal hormone therapy products. That warning had been on the label since the early 2000s, after the Women’s Health Initiative study. It listed risks of heart disease, breast cancer and probable dementia, and for many women it ended the conversation before it started.

The FDA based its decision on a review of the research, an expert panel and public comment. Much of that research points to the same idea: timing matters. Women who start hormone therapy before age 60, or within about ten years of menopause, appear to have a very different risk picture than women who start much later.

One important detail is often left out of the headlines. The FDA kept the boxed warning about cancer of the uterine lining for estrogen-only products taken by mouth or through the skin. That is why a woman who still has her uterus is usually prescribed progesterone along with estrogen. It protects the lining of the uterus.

What the new guidance says

On October 15, 2026, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) released expanded guidance on menopause care. Its main points are worth knowing:

  • ACOG gave hormone therapy a strong recommendation as a first choice for treating hot flashes and night sweats, along with the sleep problems they cause, for most healthy women who have these symptoms.
  • For women who choose hormones, ACOG advises starting before age 60 or within ten years of menopause. Some women may continue past 60 if symptoms persist.
  • The old advice to use “the lowest dose for the shortest time” was replaced with regular check-ins and an individual plan.
  • The recommendation does not apply to women with medical reasons to avoid hormones, such as a past blood clot, stroke or certain cancers.
  • ACOG did not endorse plant-based estrogens or herbal supplements, noting there is no good evidence they are safe or effective.

ACOG also lists non-hormonal options, including newer prescription medicines, certain antidepressants and approaches like cognitive behavioral therapy. Hormones are not the only path, and they are not right for everyone.

The newest heart data

Earlier this month, researchers presented a large study at the American Heart Association’s annual meeting. They followed more than 52,000 women in Israel, ages 45 to 59, for an average of about 12 years. None had heart disease, blood clots or cancer when the study began. About half started hormone therapy and half did not.

Over that time, the two groups had similar rates of heart attack, stroke, blood clots and death before age 80. The results looked similar whether women used pills, patches or gels.

This is encouraging, but I want to be clear about what it is. It was presented as a meeting abstract, which means it has not yet been published in a peer-reviewed journal. It is also an observational study, so it shows an association, not cause and effect. It is one more piece of evidence, not the final word.

No warning does not mean no risk

Since the label change, many more women have started hormone therapy. That is good news for women who have been suffering in silence. The same researchers behind the heart study made a point I agree with: a lot of that increase seems to be driven by media and social media rather than by a conversation with a physician, and some people now read the change as meaning hormones carry no risk at all.

That is not what the evidence says. Hormone therapy is a prescription medicine. The right choice depends on your age, how long it has been since menopause, your symptoms, your personal and family history, and your own risk of heart disease, breast cancer and blood clots. The type of hormone, the dose and how it is taken all matter too. Two women with the same symptoms can reasonably end up with different plans.

Questions to bring to your visit

If you are considering hormone therapy, these questions help make the most of your appointment:

  • Based on my age and when my periods stopped, where do I fall in the timing window?
  • Does anything in my history, or my family’s history, change the risks for me?
  • Do I need progesterone along with estrogen, and why?
  • Would a patch, gel, cream or pill make the most sense for me?
  • Which lab tests or screenings should I have before starting, and how often will we follow up?
  • What non-hormonal options should I consider?

How I approach it with my patients

In more than 28 years of practicing medicine, I have seen how much menopause symptoms can affect sleep, mood, focus, relationships and work. I have also seen women talked out of treatment that might have helped them, and women who wanted something that was not right for them.

My approach starts with listening. We go over your symptoms, your history and your goals, and we use lab testing where it helps. If hormone therapy makes sense for you, we talk through the options, the benefits and the risks, and we build a plan with regular follow-up. If it does not make sense, we talk about other options. Either way, the decision is made together and is based on you, not on a headline.

Learn more: Women’s Hormone Clinic.

Sources

This article is for general education and is not a substitute for medical advice. Hormone therapy is not right for everyone. Please talk with a physician about your own health.

Wondering if hormone therapy is right for you?

Talk with Dr. Garcia at our Newport Beach office.

Keep reading

This article is for general education and is not a substitute for medical advice. Please talk with a physician about your own health.

Have questions about your symptoms?

Talk with Dr. Garcia at our Newport Beach office.

Keep reading